*Updated December 2016*
I’ve avoided this post for a long, long time, but a little voice in my head (the one that sounds like Sophia on Golden Girls) has told me that I finally need to write this post. I get a LOT of emails of folks asking me which machine I like better – Cricut versus Silhouette – and which one I recommend for them to purchase.
Let me preface this post by saying that I have once worked with Silhouette (nearly 2 years ago) – and I have recently worked with Cricut. For the sake of clarity: I was given a Silhouette machine to try as a review product – as was I given a Cricut for the same reason.
So since you know that both machines were given to me by the manufacturers, neither has more weight than the other. This is my HONEST, unbiased opinion to help those of you who have asked which I prefer.
The links to both of the machines in this post are affiliate links – which means if you make a purchase from them, then I will receive a tiny portion of the profit without any additional cost to you.
This post has been updated to reflect changes in the product and my experience since originally written – so some of the comments are irrelevant, however still worth reading.
So here goes: I like both machines for different reasons. Let’s start with the Silhouette Cameo. I currently own THIS version. I’ve had it for a while now and am very comfortable with it. The newest version – the Silhouette Cameo 3 is more like the Cricut Explore Air 2, so make sure you comparison shop both models to see which one is better for you.
- There are no cartridges to buy. Images or fonts can be cut directly with the software included in the starter kit.
- Custom logos, etc. are easy to manipulate with the Silhouette software.
- Their site offers many free files to cut – buy there are also some you can purchase.
- These days both run off of software and they are both user friendly.
- You can cut the same size on either of them.
- Both operate without cartridges (but Cricut will use them.)
- They are both easy to set up, break down and put away.
- Either will cut paper, vinyl, fabric, etc. – though additional blades are required.
- Both have mobile compatible apps with bluetooth built in.
So in other words – either one can win.
***EDITED TO ADD: Please make sure to read all the comments in this post – they are a WEALTH of information!***
Nice job. I have had my Cricut awhile and got Sure Cuts A Lot software to do some of the things the silhouette does. I’ve seen some fun things with the S but not sure I can justify the price with a rarely used C on the shelf. Love this post!!
Gina!?! This isn’t hate mail, so don’t worry:) I just wish you had written this last week before I bought a Silhouette machine that is currenlty on it’s way to me. Oh well, I’ll just haver to live with it and do my best. Thanks for the honest opinion.
Jessica
stayathomeista.com
Jessica – I find that I use both my Cricut AND my Silhouette all the time. Personally, I prefer the Silhouette because of the number of images they have available.
Do you have to have an Internet connection to use the silhouette?
Tasha, No, you do not need to be connected to the internet to use the software. You will need to be connected to go to the design store to download designs (if using), but the machine can be used without any internet connection.
Could you explain diff between using software without internet and design studio? Do not mean to sound off in the blue yonder. I just got a cricut air 2 (never had any type of these products) as a birthday gift and someone then told me you should have gotten a brother scan and cut. So I am assuming they all have their own pros. I have not used my cricut alot due to trying to research and learn so I can figure it out and found it can make one more confused. Your post is ver informative. Guess me being new to crafting hobbies is why I am sort of dumb on these subjects. I got i to bible art journaling and ventured from there lol. I had to do early disabled retirement and children thought this would be a great time occupier for me. Any links for using the fonts on all the little details (as i stated some things can be very confusing). I want to make quotes for iron on and decor.
I have one last question that actually off topic. Could you recommend or offer any advice on printable iron on products? I am confused as to the best option. Should I do printable image and then cut or take extreme care and make the design with cricut and layer etc? Does the ink wash wash away on the printable iron on vinyl? I have an ink jet but was concerned with washing the garment or item and ink disappearing.
Thank you for your time you take in posting your blogs. And thanks for any advice. God bless and Merry early Christmas
Hi Flora,
I am actually going to write a blog post on most of what you are asking, I will get to it as soon as I can 🙂
Great post. I love an honest opinion and I am so glad you shared yours! Lisa~
I’m happy to hear this opinion also, because I have a barely used Cricut and was feeling the pressure to buy a Silhouette since that’s all you hear about on the blogs. I was sure I was missing out on something…glad to know I’m not!! THANKS!!
Me too! Now I feel better about the dust that’s been collecting on my Cricut. No more Silhouette envy for me.
Me three! I have a cricut too and thought I was missing out, now I too, see that I am just fine with my cricut. I have the SCAL softwear, so it is perfect for me!! Thanks Gina!
I use a Cricut and 99% of the time it’s with the Cricut Craftroom. I don’t like using it without my computer because I like to have more control. But I haven’t heard of SCAL software. Can you explain what that does and where you get it?
How’s this for you? Okay, I get the machine cuts, but what? Are the things they cut cutesy things (UGH), things only used by scrapbookers, or is there something one of them has that may be useful to someone like me who does nothing cutesy, but loves Tags, ATCs, Inchies, and anything I can get my hands on to alter? This is why I haven’t even looked at one of them. I have NO CLUE what they do!
Funny huh? I’m probably the last person on earth this ignorant of either a Cricut or a Silhouette.
Smiles~
Marilyn
Hi Marilyn,
I’m not a scrapbooker either, but I use it a lot for tags – it will cut inch circles, too – along with scalloped edge backgrounds for ATCs, etc. I also use it a lot for sign making and cutting fabric pieces for appliques.
Thanks for stopping by!
Gina
Thank you so much for posting a side by side comparison! I’ve been lusting after the Silhouette after seeing so many blogging projects completed with it, but I’m definitely no technical wizard so ease of use is a definite consideration.
I bought a Silhouette thinking I could use it to cut stencils. Unfortunately, unless the font is an actual “stencil” font, I can’t use it to make a stencil. If I do, I lose the centers out of some of the letters. Silhouette’s customer service has been no help. Needless to say, I’m REALLY disappointed in the machine.
I would not recommend it if you want to cut out lettering for signs.
Does the Cricut cut stencil font letters or regular???
♥’s
Sherry
Hi Sherry,
YES! There are cartridges that will allow you to cut out stencils that keep the “inside bits” attached – you’ll have to look at the options on the cartridges, though, to make sure it’s an option because not all of them offer it.
♥’s
Gina
Hello ladies
I am a little out of my eliment so be gentle!
I am a wood and metal box maker for a hobby and I am looking to make stencils out of thin plastic ( 1/16″ ) and also thin magnet sheets that I can use over and over with a spray paint. I need a die cut machine that can do 1/2″ lettering and numbers. Most my stensils will be 4 – 5 lines 5″ wide x 3 -4″ high with like I said, 1/2″ lettering. What machine and components would you reccomend that is sturdy enough to make multiple stensils.
Thanks for any help you can give!
Sherri I’ve cut stencils with the silhouette it’ll cut everything you need cut out it sounds like things aren’t grouped or welded together from my experience Cutting lettering takes a little bit longer to master than basic shapes.That was probably the hardest thing never having any kind of diecutter.I started straight off with a cameo because I had waited so long to get into it I watched tons of videos and studied blogs and decided on it because of all of what I have figured out to do (engraving metal,cutting clay,fabric,cake fondant,drawing with pens markers,making decals,boxes)I like to design my own images and I can take an picture and turn it into a cut file and use inkscape to turn the other formats into studio ready files so just trust me you’ll get it eventually.
This is an old post, but you can use any font to make stencils with the Silhouette. I just did it by using the knife tool to create little openings in each of the letters with holes in them (a, o, e etc).
I have only had my Silhouette for a few days and I am not a graphic designer, but the software is easy to figure out by playing around. I even made a box for my soap yesterday without a template.
I love the amount of customizing I can do with the machine. If you have no vision and need someone else to design things for you that you can cut out, get a Cricuit. If you have your own ideas, Silhouette is the way to go.
I Have To Disagree With Your Comment. The Cricut Is Very Versatile. I Use The Older Models,The Personal Cutter And The Original Expression. I did buy The SCAL (sure Cuts A Lot) Software. I Can Import, Weld, Unite, Create Logos, Design My Own Decals, Copy Logos For Companies.The Possibilities Are Almost endless. I Can’t KnocK The Silhouette, Because I Haven’t Tried It, But IMO the Cricut Is Amazing. Sorry About The Caps And Punctuation, Posted From My Phone, And Apparently, It Has A Mind Of It’s Own
gocricut – I have both the Cricut Expression and the Cricut Expression 2. I have SCAL on my Expression and would love to know how to use it in creating my own work and copying logos for some businesses that are wanting their logo on product. I have been seriously considering buying a Silhouette (like in a few days!) but if I can use what I have between the 2 Cricuts, I’d sure like to save myself $300! Instruction and advise from any and all would be very much appreciated! Thanks, Belinda (bunnee36@aol.com)
I WANT THE CURLY VINE FONT FOR VINYL IRON ONS, AND I CANT FIND THE POPULAR FONT FOR CRICUT, ANY SUGGESTIONS
Awesome to read this!! I am buying a used Cricut, and wanted to make sure I can make my own stencils – most other reads so you can’t, that you HAVE to use the cartridges. But on YouTube and on the Cricut site it looks like you can download some software that you CAN create your own stencils and designs. Now, I see you really can! THANK YOU!!
I have the old Cricut Personal cutter and I really want to do Fonts, Monograms, like so many are doing with the Silhouette but I can’t find a way to do that on my Cricut. Is there a way to not have to buy another machine. I want to see if I like doing this before I upgrade. I want to do gifts, tshirts, etc. with vinyl and etching.
Thanks for any help you can give me.
I’m sorry Beverly but just am not sure, have you tried contacting them directly?
I am looking to buy the Cricut, and will need it to cut logos out on iron on vinyl. From what I read, the ability to do this is with both machines now. Is this accurate? I have no experience doing this at all, and I have limited ability with graphic design. My hope is that I can load a file with the logo and cut? HELP!
Hey Melissa,
They are both great options so you can’t really go wrong. Youtube is a great resource as is Google, so many wonderful tutorials, good luck!
Thanks. I have neither and have been trying to decide which to go with. This info is very helpful
I love my Cricut! I have made some amazing things with it. Yes we have to replace parts … like the cutting mat which I wish I could reuse my older ones. Don’t know why I’m saving them but I’m sure there will be a way to reuse them one day. I buy my cartridges at WalMart on sale. I also like that a push of a few buttons and it does the work for you.
Alice,
I wrote a tutorial on my blog on how to re-stick your cricut mats! Hope this helps you!!
http://www.maluukkonen.blogspot.com/2012/01/how-to-make-your-cricut-mat-sticky.html
Missy
Thanks for an honest opinion, Gina!
I have a Silhouette and love it… but I use it infrequently and for basic home dec stuff and the occasional personal card. I like being able to customize images, fonts, etc. But I have 2 SILs that make tons of handmade cards and they love their Cricuts.
One thing that people also need to think about with each machine is the purpose for use. Are you making stuff for personal use or for a crafty business? Cricut has a limited ‘angel policy’ and allows you to use their cut images/shapes for resale. Silhouette, however, does not. You can’t use their images to resell. I don’t sell stuff, but if I did, I would switch to the Cricut… or try to create my own images on the Silhouette. Just one more thing to think about with this debate. Thanks again for being so honest!
That’s an excellent point, Shannon! I hadn’t even thought of it… although I did know about the Angel Policy. Thanks for the reminder!
Wow, Shannon, Thanks for pointing that out!! I do have a Silhouette and had not even considered that. I have to admit using my Silhouette intimidates me so therefore I’ve only used a time or two. Currently it just sits on my shelf collecting dust…. however our middle son is good with all things technical so we are supposed to work on figuring it out over the summer.
Thanks, Gina. I’ve been thinking of getting a Cricut and I think you just confirmed it for me. Also, what Shannon says is important because I do plan to sell some of the stuff I make.
Hi Gina! I big puffy heart my Cricut! No hate mail from me.
Good points, Gina! The Sure Cuts A Lot software for Cricut does allow you to cut custom logos. Anything you create you can save in a vector format and it will cut with that software. The software cost $80 when I bought it, but you don’t have to buy the cartridges which can be pricey.
Hi. So glad I read this. I have a cricut. Someone told me about Sure-Cuts-A Lot software. I have the old cricut expressions, not the cricut 2. I heard you can’t download the Sure Cuts A Lot software with the Cricut 2. Is that true? I don’t even know how to download sure cuts a lot. Ha! But I do want to learn more about how to use my cricut. I have 3 little girls and another (unknown gender) on the way. I have all these ideas, but can’t afford cartridges.
Thanks for your review, Gina. I gifted my granddaughter with a Cricut machine a couple of Christmases ago and she is going to bring it back to me as she never uses it. Good to know you love yours. She said she needed to buy new sticky mats real often even tho she barely used hers. Any tips on making them last longer?
I’m hosting my annual WEDDING BLOG PARTY on June 8th and would love for you to join us!! Come read all about it!
Big TX Hugs,
Stephanie
Stephanie, youtube has lots of tutorials to re-sticky (is that a word?)mats–it’s easy and saves a lot of $.
Be aware that this trick can void your warranty (mine is out anyway and I’ve had no problems with the trick). I reuse my mats MANY times by using the “SLICE” kit manufactured for making their mats sticky again (not familiar with their product). I simply use a foam brush, squeeze some on the mat and spread it thinly. Let it dry about 10 minutes and you are ready to go. Warning: VERY sticky to start with, so use thicker papers until it wears down.
I’ve always rubbed just a little bit of glue stick on my mats to re-stick them… let the mat dry for a few minutes..
I’ve bought mats off eBay before for half off retail. Also, I’ve used both the Silhouette and Cricut mats and the Silhouette mats are much stickier initially than the Cricut mats. When I bought the Cricut mats I was a little disappointed because I couldn’t use it to cut fabric as it wasn’t sticky enough.
Thanks for this; I’ve been researching which machine I want to get, and this really helps to weigh out my options. Now to just make up my mind.:) I think I’m leaning towards the Cricut, though.
Thanks for your opinion (which I vaue) and helping me to love my Cricut. I have had Silouette envy for a while too, but this post nipped that in the bud!
I’m computer savvy and use graphics programs in my work, so frankly, I just didn’t want to feel as if I was working by being hooked up to the computer! I’ve been using the Cricut for years and even bought the Gypsy several years ago (doesn’t FEEL like work!).
I have too many carts, but have bought them fairly cheaply using eBay, etc. I have never paid retail, or even close.
I drag this workhorse to retreats and crops a couple time a month. It seems quite sturdily built and it feels like my HOBBY. The Gypsy makes it easier to manipulate the images/fonts too. I’m a huge fan of using the Gypsy, but then again, I have no interest in being hooked up to a computer, even for the Craft Room.
fantastic post! From what I have read, I am not the only one who thinks this. I have been thinking that I needed to have a sillouhete to be happy, your post reminded me of how happy I already am with my cricut. Thanks so much for taking the time to compare them side by side and voicing your true opinion. Awesome post!
Thanks for sharing!
Have a happy day!
♥Tausha
sassystyleredesign.com
Great post! I debated this myself around last November. I debated between the cricut and the silhouette cameo. I decided to go with the Silhouette Cameo due to the fact that the creations were almost endless with the ability to design on the computer. I didn’t like having to buy the expensive cartridges and need only a few items off of the cartridge. I was not disappointed at all with the cameo. Some of your cons have been fixed. I haven’t seen the Silhouette SD but the Cameo is very sturdy and comes with a 12 x 12 mat. I believe there is a 12×24 available mat also.
I’ve been playing with the machine in my free time over the last few months. I’m not a computer expert (pharmacist by day) but the software was pretty quick to learn. The silhouette blog has tons of tips and I started following several blogs that use the machine. I’ll admit that it was a little overwhelming at first but after making a couple cards. I feel like I have a great hold on the program.
I actually have been experimenting tweaking bought designs or building my own designs. A cool feature is that you can drop a picture into the program. Trace a shape on it (i.e. a wedding cake) and cut it. No cost of design (which are 0.99 cents). You can also send the studio file through your printer and then cut out the design on the cameo.
With all that being said. I’m glad to see someone putting an opinion out there! Comparisons seem to be far and few between. Thanks! 🙂
Gina,
Thank you so much for taking the time to post this! I have been lusting after the Silhouette machine after reading about all the bloggers who use it. Now I can see that, based on my limited tech skills, I might be better off with the Cricut! You were so generous to share this information, and the responses have been very helpful, as well!
I love my Cricut. I agree – the cartridges are pricey but I have found them cheaper on Ebay (compared to Michael’s and AC Moore). What I love best about it is I can go a month or so not using it and then I re-discover it and fall in love all over again with what it can do. I got mine for $99 – a black Friday deal as well. God, almost 3 years ago?????
Jeanine
great post. I also had silhouette envy as well. but the cricut was local got it for a good price.I put it on an old type writer table so I flip up the sides and I don’t have to clear off counter/table so set up is crazy easy ;)[ got the table at a thrift store $15.00. The new cartridges are pretty cool boxes cupcake liners paper flowers ect. I am not a scapbooker either . made soom really cool chalkboard tags really easy.
ok gals got a question . tried to cut out some letters on heavy glitter paper even put in deep set blade also some thinner glitter paper what a dang mess. I know it prob is operater error what should I have done ?? also does it cut felt?
Colleen did you use the pressure setting on the highest level? I’ve cut glittered cardstock with mine before and didn’t have an issue. And is your blade new? New blades make a big difference when cutting glittered stuff or fabric 🙂
Thanks for stopping by!
Oh this is fabulous information! I asked a salesperson at Michael’s and she told me that it wouldn’t cut glitter cardstock! Now I’ll just buy the deep cut blade.
Good to hear! I see so many Silhouette give-away dealies in blogland…that it made me wonder. I’ve had the big ol’ Cricut for a couple of years now…and have yet to take it out of the box. Ooops. Soon, I will…I hope.
Thank you for the scoop!
: )
Julie M.
Gina,
Loved your post BTW! I haven’t really seen many people review the two so I was definitely interested to see what you were going to say. So, let me also preface this by saying I’ve also worked with the Silhouette company but HAVE used both machines at some point in time.
I was once a graphic designer as well! And while I will say that in terms of speed the Cricut is better (because you don’t have to hook it up to a computer and fiddle with software), I would recommend the Silhouette HANDS DOWN. But that’s mostly because EVERYTHING I cut is customized and I took to their software quite quickly.
I can EASILY see how a lot of people would find the software too difficult to get full use of it. But if you can master the software it’s like having your own print shop. A couple weeks ago I made custom tees for our girl scout troop that would never have been able to do with the Cricut. I personally love using the machine in conjunction with the computer. I feel blind using the Cricut without one.
And the Silhouette can cut up to 12″ so that’s awesome! I would never pay $70 for a cartridge that only printed a limited number of things. But then again, as I said before, everything I’ve used the Silhouette for is custom jobs. But if you’re a scrapbooker or just use it for things like labels than maybe the Cricut IS for you.
I guess it’s all about how good you are at figuring out software and what you plan on using the machine for. For me, the Silhouette works.
Thank you for the honest review. I have a Cricut, and I love it! I don’t scrapbook, but I use it to make decorations, cards, banners,etc. I restick the mats by spraying them w/ repositionable stencil adhesive. Works like a charm and the $5 can of adhesive is still 1/2 full after using it for a year. I’ve had the machine for two years and have only replaced the blades a couple of times.
I am happy to hear this as well! I have a cricut that was given to me by my mil way back when they first came out. But when all these bloggers started receiving silhouettes to review…I admit I had a bit of blog envy. So happy to put my thoughts at ease! 😉
Though I think I would really enjoy the sil, from how you compared it, I usually only use the cricut for projects that I am cutting out 20 circles. So it sounds like for me I have the right product!
Great topic! I think the choice between the two machines would depend a lot on how one plans to use it.
I have had the Cricut (6″) for a several years and used to use it a lot with SCAL. But when I switched to using a Mac, my software wouldn’t work and so I purchased the Silhouette Cameo. I love my Cameo!! It allows me to create my own designs and to use fonts from my computer and even manipulate them. I do still use my Cricut if I need something from one of the cartridges.
Are you saying that the Cricut software doesn’t work with a Mac? That’s a dealbreaker for me. Shucks.
I bought a Cricut recently, thinking I could buy the SCAL software to use with it. I didn’t realize that Cricut has “outlawed” SCAL, and it will no longer work with it. My understanding is that if you already had SCAL before the legal battle, you can still use it, but what you buy now will no longer work. I was really disappointed, and ended up buying a Sihlouette too.
I have both now, and usually use the Sihlouette. I’m still figuring out their software, but overall, I find it to be rather easy to use. I’m at the “tweaking” stage now.
I haven’t decided whether to keep the Cricut too or not. For now, I probably will. I’ve only used the tiny screen on the machine itself, and I find it uncomfortable to use. I haven’t taken the time to hook it up to the computer to use their software, and don’t know if I want too, since my Sihlouette is already hooked up to my computer. My desk isn’t that big. lol
Awesome post Gina! Thanks for being your honest self.
I too had “silhouette envy” I’m glad to read this bost! I wish I could figure out how to use cricut craft room with it…I think that would be helpful for me since I have the older cricut!
Thanks for the post! It made me feel better about keeping my cricut!
Hi, Gina, thanks for all of your hard work & creative insight. I have a Cricut machine & have played around with Cricut Craft Room a little, but have never cut anything from it & really want to start using it more. This is my dilemma, I really wanted to be able to cut SVG’s so, I bought SCAL v2 last week (I have not installed it yet). I was told that the SCAL v2 would still work with my Cricut Expression (Firmware 2.34) as long as I did not update the firmware to 2.43. The problem is, I have recently read that I won’t be able to use Cricut Craft Room to cut with if I don’t update the firmware to 2.43. I was wondering if I could use both SCAL & Craft Room with my machine as long as I turned off one of them before using the other. If this is not possible, if it will damage my Expression or hender my ability to use Cricut Craft Room, then I was thinking of perhaps keeping my Expression just to use with SCAL v2 & buying another Cricut machine to use/cut with Craft Room. I was also thinking that maybe I should just keep my Expression for Craft Room (& update it to 2.43) & buy another Die Cut machine that is compatible with SCAL software. I’m so confused with all of this that I can’t think straight, much less make a decision on what to do! I’m hoping that you can help me decide what my best option is & please share any other knowledge you have on this topic, Thanks so much!!!
So, I tried to read through your post and all the comments as best I could. But, I’m still no closer to understanding what would be best for my needs. I have always wanted a cutter but couldn’t justify the expense for the occasional hobby. Now, however, my current job requires a few simple signs be made from time to time, vinyl lettering for walls and glass. I desperately want to make my own wall decals essentially and want some flexibility in design…color I assume would come from the vinyl itself. Basic shapes would be great and maybe a small logo or two.
I tried asking on twitter but with few followers no one would answer me. What would you all recommend? I have no clue! I heard a brief comment from a you tube video that for lettering the Silhouette is best with transfer tape or something. What do you say? I’d appreciate any suggestions!
Thanks for the honest review and comments ya’ll.
If you want flexibility, then the Silhouette would probably be better for you. The newer version has come a long way from the original one I tested. Now I use it as much as I do my Cricut 🙂
Thanks!
I thought you could no longer use SCAL with Cricut machines. Isn’t this true. I would love to be able to use fonts from my computer with my Cricut.
If You Have The Older Versions (Original ExPression Or Personal Cutter), SCAL Will Still Work With Them. Finding The Software May Be A Problem. SCAL 2 is The Last Version That Will Work With cricut
My Silhouette Portrait arrives tomorrow, but I’m thinking of exchanging it for the Cameo. The Cameo can cut without being hooked up to a computer. You transfer your designs onto a card and then pop the SD card into the Cameo then select which designs to cut or draw. There is still some computer involvement, but while the Portrait has to be connected to a PC to work, the Cameo doesn’t. The Cameo has a 12×12 cutting area and costs $100 more than the Portrait. I isn’t think the extra area mattered $100 worth, but not having to be tethered to a computer is another story.
I am thinking of buying a cricut. I am a designer myself and I was wondering whether I can make my own designs and cut them with it. Does it work with ai. files ?
Hi Irini,
Silhouette have come out with Connect, which allows you to send files from Illustrator to the Silhouette cutter. I’ve been researching, haven’t bought one yet myself. Information on that software can be found here:
http://www.silhouetteamerica.com/shop/software-and-download-cards/item-group/silhouette-connect
However, other options include exporting your .ai files as .dxf, which the included software can read, or buying the Designer Edition upgrade for the included software, which can read .svg files, which you can also create with Illustrator.
Again, I’m not an expert, just done a ton of research over the past few weeks and thought this info might be helpful to you 🙂
Karin, Just want to mention that you don’t need designer edition software to cut svg files. You can convert svg to other formats like .dxf using inkscape (free software), which can be sent to your silhouette for cutting. Go here http://michellesdigitalcreations.blogspot.ca/2012/01/converting-svg-files-to-use-with.html for the tut on converting svg files using inkscape.
Thank you very much for the informative post and great comments. I am very curious to know which machine is currently better at cutting fabric for appliqués? I have the cricut expression and attempted cutting fabric a few times but found I was using a blade to hand cut a lot of the pieces out that didn’t fully cut. I didn’t play around much with pressure or using the deep blade do that could be my problem… But I’m very curious about how well the cameo cuts fabric? Also, have you used the great transfers with the cameo? If so, how is the feel of it once ironed? Does it feel stiff and uncomfortable or is it fairly soft and plyable? Do you know how well they wash? Thank you for any info!!
Sorry, that should say “heat” transfers not “great” transfers..
Amanda, I do heat transfer tees all the time (now my home business)…the vinyl has a very soft feel to it once pressed on. Not stiff at all! Just wash it inside out on cold and hang dry or dry on low heat. Holds up wonderfully!
This is why I chose a Silhouette over the Cricut and have never regretted the decision. By the way I have the Cameo which takes a 12″ mat ans I have both a 12×12 and 12×24. You can manipulate your own images without the use of a cartridge. I just did 30 hoodies with heat transfer vinyl and my Cameo. I had a jpeg of the team logo emailed to me and I was able to copy a very intricate logo without issue.
Now….that being said….I had tons of trial and error to perfect the Cameo! You have to know how to manipulate images, work with the make/release compound path feature etc to be able to copy images successfully. It took lots of practice, internet searches and video watching to make this happen. :). I also had to play around with the blade settings. I have read that this is a quirk of the Silhouette. My vinyl wouldn’t cut properly on the default setting but after experimenting with the pressure of the blade it works perfectly.
I have built a business with this machine. I am always busy because I can customize pretty much anything without the cost of cartridges . I make my own rhinestone transfers as well as the wall vinyl sayings. In fact I never buy from the Silhouette store, no need to. I made all my own Christmas gifts with this, even cute gift labels. Well worth the cost!
I promise once you get around the learning curve the sky’s the limit with the Cameo!!
Jennifer, how do you transfer your vinyl to your shirts? Do you use a regular iron? Thanks in advance for any info!
Which cameo do you have if you don’t mind my asking?
DO NOT BUY THE CRICUT!!
I spent a ton of money on the Cricut Imagine and cartridges/supplies and have had nothing but problems. The machine only works half the time, it doesn’t work with the Cricut Craft Room, and the customer service is terrible! I have had to call several times and each time I’m put on hold for a half hour or more and every time I am only given half-answers and temporary “solutions” to my problems. The support employees do not know anything about the product, they just read from scripts! I was transferred to the “Craft Room” section and the woman couldn’t even open CCR on her end! She couldn’t even open the only program her support section is responsible for! I was transferred yet again to a guy that spent an hour trying to solve my problem – he took over my computer remotely and everything – and still couldn’t figure it out. He promised to email me the next day with a solution and he NEVER did. Even after I emailed him back several times asking about it, I still got nothing. I have put in several comments on their “contact us” webpage and each time they say you can expect a response within 5-7 business days but I have NEVER received a response. Provo Craft does not care about their customers. Their “support” is a joke. They just take your money and run! DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY ON CRICUT / PROVO CRAFT!!
I have read many different sites about that Cricut can cut paper, but each time we try the paper tears. I am talking about designer paper not card stock. Is anybody able to help me? tia
Bobbi, you just need to adjust the pressure setting. The thinner the paper, the lower the setting. That should fix it!
DO NOT BUY CRICUT. I bought one and was so excited. Even bought a few cartridges. After I did more erase arch I realized Cameo was the way to go and I got rid of the Cricut. Cameo has limitless possibilities basically being able to cut anything your heart desires where as Cricut you are stuck with limited crap on cartridges and most of the time you only need that 1-2 image on each cartridge. Repeat . DO NOT BUY CRICUT. It would be like buying a tape player Walkman in 2014. Who does that!
I just wanted to mention that the silhouette store DOES have the option to purchase the designs for using on products that you’re going to re-sell ( comparable to the circuits angel policy) the price depends how many items you’re planning on selling w the design The prices are very reasonable
First of all, the original post is old and silhouette has new machines/software now. I never owned this until 2 months ago and it’s my first ever die cut machine! I love my silhouette portrait which cuts letter and legal size paper/media at most but it’s sufficient for my use. I can however cut 9 ft long vinyl as long as the width is 9″ max. Software is really easy to use and I did a cut within half hour of opening the box! I have no graphic design background or degree whatsoever. Granted I took the free design (50 free!) and went with it and it did a beautiful job. If you do unusual sizes or media, you will need to fiddle with the blade depth and speed but you get to know it pretty quickly. I have basic software and I even figured out (via google) how to cut svg files on my portrait and it did it! Look around, some phenomenal tuts out there for everything you need. At the cost 50 cents a design more often than not (or $0.99 worst case), Cricut can’t beat the price. I agree that the machine may look a bit flimsy but I am pretty careful with everything I buy, so I should be OK. I cut very intricate doilies and backgrounds within the first month, great job as long as I use card stock that is not too fibrous (even then it was OK). Reg white/beige cs pack from Joann/Michaels worked great.
I am wanting to find a machine that will cut stencils (for making wooden signs) and am cluelss about these machines! I want to be able to use my own designs…any thoughts??
I love my silhouette it was difficult in the beginning to learn how to use it but now i absolutely love it, i think is the best investment I’ve had done so far, i was not sure about which one to buy and after doing some reviews i decided on my cameo, the size mat had been addressed with this model. I don’t need to buy cartridges and even though its pricy im saving in the long run. I can print pretty much anything i want.
I love my machine!!!! and i haven’t even use it to her maximum capabilities.
PS: i don’t work for silhouette, in case you wonder.
I am wondering which one would be best for my scrapbooking and card making needs. I have read all the reviews, and saw how people use different mediums that need to be cut, but I would just use card stock. I would need one that could do the fonts I have on my computer if possible and cut cleanly. Also one with low maintenance which would be nice. I want to get one but just want to make the best decision for my use. Please let me know. Thanks for your time. 🙂
I purchased a Cricut Expression along with the SCAL Software a year ago, and I luv it!! There is no need to purchase any cartridges. I get free images off the web all the time or friends have shared their svg images with me. So far I have made shirts using HTV(Heat transfer vinyl), car decals, personalized gifts from picture frames, balloons, walls, tumblers and the list goes on. Now I’m looking into cutting rhinestone templates with my Cricut. The possibilities are endless. So for people to say they are limited with the Cricut, I shake my head in confusing and want to know why. I only used the Cricut and had no problems so far. I’ll stick with my Cricut for now.
I have owned a Cricut since the first one came out. I taught scrapbooking and card making at Joann as an evening job since I was a former teacher turned stay at home mom. When it first came out I was amazed. I have since come to despise the machine and the company. I have Silhouette envy. I have cut many things on my Cricut but I am sure I have voided the warranty 800 times. Provocrap is the most costumer non friendly business I have ever seen. There is a reason I shop at certain stores and only buy certain products…because I care about being treated respectfully. I purchased the Cricut Design Studio and I had to call the company to tell them how to make the setting right on my brand new computer to make it work. That computer program was horrific. I bought SCAL when it first came out…it was OK but was just too clumsy for me. I then bought MTC and I loved it. Then PC sues the creators of MTC. Did you know you do not have the right to do whatever you want with the machine YOU PURCHASED!!! ???? Their angel policy is absolutely ridiculous. The teachers at my children’s school got a grant to get a Cricut and you know what? It is still in the box after three years. No one wants to touch it because it is a pain in the booty. I am currently in the market for a Silhouette and as soon as I can get one I am going to boot the bug!
I came upon this page when I was looking at buying stencils, stencil makers. I’ve recently started chalk painting and find that I don’t see a stencil in the local store that I like or would prefer to make my own. It seems like everyone goes between both brands, I need one that can cut stencil plastic, without connecting to a computer as I don’t have one just my phone and my nook which doesn’t serve as a secure internet line so it won’t let me do some things. But I would like to be able to design my own stencil. Does a machine that does all of this even exist? I’ve tried looking at stats and reviews but can’t come up with an answer.
Ty
I am so excited to try my new cricut, thanks for the honest opinion, I was given a silhouette card for Christmas from a friend, is there anything I can buy there at silhouette to use with my new cricut.
Hi, this may be off topic, but does anyone know if you can buy a used Cricut and use it on your computer. I heard that once it’s installed, you can’t use it elsewhere. Any advice is helpful. Thanks!
Thanks for providing unbiased information! It would be very useful for me as I am a craftaholic person and I am going to buy cricut machines for doing my art work.
Great read. Also, it was updated Dec 2016 I assume and not Dec 2017 unless you can time travel.
Thanks Melissa 🙂
Which one is better for fabric?
I really couldn’t say Sandi, they both have their pros and cons 🙂
I’m just now looking into these two options. I want something to make decals and wall art with, preferably only using my ipad. Which would you recommend for this beginner?? 😉
Oh Amber, I can’t really do that, it is a
:)very personal decision and I like them both. I’d suggest re reading my post and see which one feels like a better fit for you.
I just wanted to say thank you for taking the time to write this review. I was debating on what machine to consider purchasing and your information was invaluable! I’ve never seen your blog before but will be signing up for emails. I have been doing my own signs by hand and want to move forward with more elaborate signs and believe this information as well as your blog will be of great use.
Yea! I am so glad it helped Sandy 🙂 Best of luck to you and welcome to my blog!!
Hello,I log on to your new stuff named “Twitter” like every week.Your story-telling style is awesome, keep up the good work! And you can look our website about love spell.
Thank you and I will 🙂
This may have been asked in the comments but I could not read it all and I may have overlooked it in the article as I am running g on super slow data right now and also super slow no sleep “mommy we are up” time lol. But I just recently got into all of this and this is going to be my first investment for myself. I was a bit confused on whether or not you were saying with this version of the Silhouette we COULD create our own designs? I have baseball teams and schools I wanted to create designs for and I wanted to make sure I could design my own before i made this purchase.
Hey Kelley,
You can now create your own designs on either machine, so you are fine whichever machine you decide to go with 🙂 Good luck!
I am mainly interested in drawing images, importing them via cell phone camera into a software program, and making stickers from them. So I need a machine that will do half cuts and full cuts. Do you have a recommendation?
It sounds like the two machines you’ve reviewed can do so much more, yet I don’t really want to pay for things I don’t need or won’t use.
Thank you!
I do not know, I am only familiar with these since I have used them. Maybe check with your local craft stores to see if they might have any ideas or recommendations. Good luck!
Gina,
I want to thank you for your unbiased reviews of these 2 machines! I am buying one for my girl friend, whose birthday is this Saturday. She is big into crafting, and lately she has been buying lots of stencils online, and at stores. (She is doing a lot of decorative and seasonal paint schemes on wood blocks these days, snowflakes, etc). I began shopping for a machine recently, and was undecided, but leaning toward the Silhouette 3 bundle because of the favorable price, thanks to your info it sounds like that is going to work for her. Hopefully it can also do vinyl letters/numbers approximately 6 inches tall, (competition numbers for our son’s off-road motorcycles, and my drag race cars), that would be a bonus money saver.
I knew exactly nothing about these machines, until I read your great detailed information, and learned lots from the other commenters as well.
Thanks, y’all! I will recommend your website to her! -Dan.
Thanks so much Dan! I am sure she will love it, what an awesome birthday gift!! Happy Birthday from me 🙂
I am fortunate enough to own the latest version of both machines, and although the I love the speed of the Cricut Explore Air II , I tend to use my Silhouette more often as I like the design software much better. Also, Cricut designs are much better these days, but I have always leaned towards the Silhouette designs as I found the Cricut designs to be too child-like. Obviously that is perfectly suited for crafters with small children, so it is nice to have choices to suit all styles.
Thanks so much Julie for your helpful insight 🙂 Happy New Year!
ok… this may be a stupid question, but, can i use a plain old iron to apply htv? or do i need a special heat press machine? – specifically for cloth items.
also, for the time being, i am more interested in getting a machine that will allow me to create my own reusable stencils (fonts, shapes, etc). any recs for this? is one better than the other FOR THIS APPLICATION? or can you recommend a less-pricey alternative?
You can use a regular iron and what you are looking for is exactly what both of these machines do. Just read the post as it goes over the pros and cons of both 🙂
I recently went to the Pinners Conference in Atlanta. Awesome review and remarks, but after reading all this, I am overwhelmed with information!! My big question is – since the comparison is 2 years old, are these the latest and greatest of both machines? I’ve been looking at both of them on Amazon and all the new models come up. I am happy to check YouTube to compare the newer ones you currently recommend. Thanking you in advance for your insite.
Hi Mary, they have most likely come out with newer models since this post but since I do not have the newer models I can’t really give you advice. I think they are both good machines from good companies so you would probably be fine with either one 🙂 Good luck!
I actually have a question, but first.. some history: Many years ago, I owned a Wishblade and could do just about anything with it once I made it past the learning curve. The problem I had with it was that it was SO LOUD and SLOW! I upgraded to a KNK after about 1 year (the big huge bulky one that still had some bugs in the software). The KNK software of that era had a HUGE learning curve, and I never quite mastered it. Unfortunately, a pressure foot on the machine broke during a move, and I quit using it all together. I miss my cutter, but do not wish to even try to learn that wretched software for my KNK. I want something easier to use, however I have THOUSANDS of files that I designed in other programs {like Inkscape, Robocraft (I think), and others} saved in EPS, SVG or DXF formats. Which cutter would be easiest to use with the files I have designed? What software does each cutter come with?
Thanks so much!!
Hi Pam, I am not sure I think it would be in your best interest to contact both companies and ask them directly as they know far more than I do . Good luck!
I don’t know how long you used the Cricut. But I’m switching after using the Cricut for a year. They have way to many hiccups for my liking. I can go on and on with all of Cricuts issues that after a year they still haven’t fixed. It is constantly going down. The design Space that is where you do your work. Read carefully alll the fb sites. Customers are several x a day seeking is anyone elseis having issues with design Space. You can only work if you have wifi. Their font review had problems. You must spell a word and then click on about 40% of the fonts until you find the design you want. There is no tumbler blank so you can place words that will slightly curve so when placed for word is straight on cup or rounded object. The art clean up area stools leaves jagged edges about 85% instead of clean crisp lines. You have to go out of design Space into a separate program do your design save and then download into DS. It is frustrating using Cricuts software so many hiccups. If you are going to use it for Cricut projects and fonts only, you’ll love it. If you are a creative person who wants a machine to grow with you it’s not Cricut. It is crazy all these sites planning Cricut on top of their lists when they have so many issues with their software. I cringe everytime i have touse mine. Next purchase is silhouette.
Sorry about all the mis spelled words. Doing this on my phone abdthe does are too tiny. Lol
Hi maybe you can help me please. I’ve been wanting to make stencils to do face painting and airbrush on stencils on cakes. May I ask which machine can make these sort of stencils or the stencils that have sticky backs to make reusable stencils? I like having it WiFi accessible and yes pricing is important but if it has more capabilities I’m ok with buying a extra cartridge here or there. Also are the bundles Cricut offers useful and needed or just unnecessary and pricey?
Thanks
Hi Jennifer, I recommend the silhouette- I think it will suit your purposes best but they are both good machines so you really can’t go wrong 🙂
Hi Jennifer, I recommend the silhouette- I think it will suit your purposes best but they are both good machines so you really can’t go wrong 🙂
Hi there,
I am new to sign making and as of right now have been doing all my signs by hand. I am interested in purchasing a machine to essentially cut stencils for me. Do you have any advice? What would you recommend?
Hi Charmaine, both machines are equally good and I don’t have a preference of one over the other, my advice is to go with the best deal as they are both great choices 🙂
I know very little about either machine but am starting to research. I need to make stencils (assuming out of sticky backed vinyl?), to make quotes and words in a fairly small font. I work with glass and will be using the stencils to etch glass with. Any lean one way or another? I’d also like to use my own logo to etch on some things so need that availability as well. Thanks for any and all recommendations. Again, I’m a total newbie.
In all seriousness LJ they are both equally as good. I have both and really don’t favor one over the other. Maybe go with the one you can get a better deal on? Sounds like an awesome project, good luck!
I want to add one note of caution. According to the Wikipedia article on the Cricut, the manufacturer has a history of sunseting equipment, cartridges, and software. The original software is no longer available, and the newer software doesn’t work with the old models, so people who bought one of the old machines have been left holding devices that no longer work.
According to the Wiki article, Provo Craft has also been draconian about third party software, successfully sueing two third-party software companies for having the gall of writing software that interfaced with the Cricut. While this might not affect very many people, you have to decide how you feel about that. I’m a professional software developer, so I find this draconian practice quite disturbing.
Again, from the Wiki article: All cartridges work only with Cricut software , must be registered to a single user for use and cannot be sold or given away. A cartridge purchased for a discontinued machine is likely to become useless at the point the machine is discontinued. Cricut reserves the right to discontinue support for some versions of their software at any time, which can make some cartridges immediately obsolete.
I am unassociated with either manufacturer. I started looking into this as my wife was given a Cricut by someone who no longer used it, and like a good husband, I’m trying to support her while providing myself with a never-ending list of Christmas and Birthday Present ideas.
Thanks for the insight Joe 🙂
I’m a little upset about this review which upon i made my decision to buy Cricut some time ago. I was hoping that this machine will help me to produce products to sell. If you want to print something on a cardboard and cut it with Cricut, “Good Lock” because it’s very very hard to make the adjustment to the machine to cut it as it suppose to. I did search and search and search and turn things over and over and always finish by having a gap wrong. Maybe there is other machine out there that i don’t know, making the d’job. I wouldn’t advise anyone to buy this machine.
The machines are meant to be used with vinyl for stenciling, I’m not sure they are supposed to be used with something as thick as cardboard. Perhaps you should contact them directly for advice?